DiagnosticsNurses Association Opposes Mandatory Flu Shots For Health Workers
Speaking at a meeting of the New
York State Hospital Planning and Review Council, the New York State Nurses
Association strongly opposed a regulation that would require every
healthcare worker in the state to be immunized for influenza.
Despite these objections, the council adopted the proposal as an emergency
rule that could go into effect before this winter"s flu season. The rule
affects all healthcare personnel, both paid and unpaid, who interact with
patients in hospitals, diagnostic and treatment centers, certified home
health agencies, long-term healthcare programs, AIDS home care programs,
licensed home care services, and hospices.
In its testimony, the Nurses Association called the council"s action a
"scorched earth" approach. "While we encourage nurses to be immunized for
the flu, we do not agree that nurses should be required to get
immunizations as a condition of employment," said Eileen Avery, RN,
associate director of the association"s Education, Practice & Research
Program.
"The seasonal flu vaccine is not 100% effective and sometimes is highly
ineffective, as it was in 2005 and 2007," Avery said. "There is no
guarantee that in any given year, the public will benefit from mandatory
immunization of healthcare providers."
The Nurses Association also is concerned that the state and healthcare
facilities might rely upon flu shots to prevent the spread of influenza
among workers and patients rather than implementing proven infection
control procedures such the use of appropriate respirators and isolation
rooms.
The regulation"s impact on the state"s shortage of nurses could be
significant.
"There is no exemption for religious or cultural preferences regarding
immunization, effectively blocking individuals who have these beliefs from
earning their livelihood," Avery said. "It"s possible that nurses will
leave the profession or choose another career because of this onerous
mandate; a serious threat at a time when the shortage of nurses in New York
State is expected to reach 20,000 within a decade."
New York State Nurses÷ Association